If you're looking into affordable housing, you've probably run into the term "Section 8" more than once. But here's something many people don't know: Section 8 isn't just one program. It's actually two different types of help, and they work in very different ways.
The two main types are Project-Based Section 8 and the Housing Choice Voucher (also called tenant-based Section 8). Both help you pay rent. Both are run by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). But how you use them, where you can live, and how you apply are not the same at all.
This guide breaks down the difference in simple terms, so you can figure out which option fits your situation best.
Think of it this way: one type of help follows you wherever you rent. The other type of help stays attached to one building, no matter who lives there. That one difference changes almost everything about how you search, apply, and plan your next move.
Get instant answers to your housing questions.Chat Now
What Is the Housing Choice Voucher Program?
The Housing Choice Voucher (HCV) program is what most people picture when they hear "Section 8." It's a voucher that goes to you, the renter, not to a specific building.
Here's how it works: once you're approved, you get a voucher. You then look for an apartment or house on the private market — any landlord who agrees to accept the voucher and meets basic safety standards can rent to you. You typically pay about 30% of your household income toward rent, and your local Public Housing Agency (PHA) pays the rest directly to your landlord, according to HUD's official Housing Choice Vouchers Fact Sheet.
The biggest advantage of this voucher is choice. You're not stuck picking from a small list of buildings. You can search neighborhoods, compare units, and pick a home that works for your job, your kids' school, or your family's needs. If you ever need to move, in most cases you can take your voucher with you to a new home, and sometimes even to a new city, through a process called portability.
There is a trade-off, though. Because you're searching the open rental market, you still have to find a landlord who is willing to accept your voucher, and in some areas that can take time. Once you find a unit, the PHA will need to inspect it to make sure it's safe and meets basic housing quality standards before your lease can start. This adds a step to the process, but it also protects you as a renter, since you won't end up in a unit with serious safety problems.
What Is Project-Based Section 8?
Project-Based Section 8 works differently. Instead of the subsidy following you, it's attached to a specific apartment or building. This is officially called Project-Based Rental Assistance (PBRA), and there's a related program called Project-Based Vouchers (PBV).
With this type of housing, a landlord or property owner has a contract with HUD or the local housing authority. That contract sets aside a certain number of units in the building as affordable housing. If you're approved for one of those units, you also pay around 30% of your income toward rent, and HUD covers the rest — but you have to live in that specific unit to keep getting help.
The catch is this: if you move out, the assistance stays behind with the apartment. It does not travel with you. The next eligible family on the waiting list moves in and takes over the subsidized rent, not you.
There is some good news here, though. If you live in a Project-Based Section 8 unit for at least one year and follow your lease rules, you may become eligible to request a Housing Choice Voucher instead. That can give you more freedom to move later on without starting over on a long waiting list.
Project-Based Section 8 comes in a couple of forms. Some units are covered under older contracts called Project-Based Rental Assistance (PBRA), which have existed since the 1970s. Others are covered under the newer Project-Based Voucher (PBV) program, which lets local housing authorities attach a portion of their vouchers to specific properties. Both work the same way from a renter's point of view: the help stays with the address, not the household. Today, well over a million households across the country live in homes supported by one of these project-based programs.
You'll often find Project-Based Section 8 housing in buildings that were specifically built or renovated with affordable housing in mind. This includes many apartment communities designed for seniors, people with disabilities, or families, and some buildings even offer on-site services like case management. Because the housing was built for this purpose, the units themselves are sometimes newer or better maintained than what you might find searching the open market with a voucher.
Get instant answers to your housing questions.Chat Now
How the Two Programs Compare
How to Apply for Each Program
For a Housing Choice Voucher: You apply through your local Public Housing Agency. Many PHAs manage their waiting lists online, and some only open applications for a short window of time, so it helps to check often. You can find your local PHA's contact information through HUD's Public Housing Agency directory.
For Project-Based Section 8: You don't go through the PHA first. Instead, you apply directly with the property. Every subsidized building keeps its own separate waiting list, so it can help to apply to several buildings at once to improve your odds. You can search for HUD-subsidized apartments near you using the HUD Affordable Housing search tool.
Income limits apply to both programs, and they're based on your household size and the median income in your area. In general, your income cannot go over 50% of the area median income to qualify, and PHAs are required to give most of their vouchers to households earning 30% or less of that median, as explained in HUD's official fact sheet.
Keep in mind that waiting lists for both programs can be long, and many close from time to time simply because there are more applicants than available openings. When a list is closed, you can't apply until it reopens, so it's worth checking back regularly or signing up for alerts if your local PHA or a property offers them. Once a list reopens, spots can fill up fast, so applying as soon as you're able gives you the best shot.
Get instant answers to your housing questions.Chat Now
What Documents Do You Need to Apply?
Most housing authorities and property managers ask for similar information, whether you're applying for a voucher or a project-based unit. Having these ready ahead of time can make the process faster:
- Proof of identity for everyone in your household, such as a driver's license or ID card
- Social Security numbers for household members
- Proof of income, including pay stubs, benefit letters, or tax returns
- Proof of any assets, like bank statements
- Your current address and rental history
Requirements can vary slightly from one housing authority or property to the next, so it's a good idea to ask directly what they need before you submit your application.
Common Questions About Section 8 Housing
Can I apply for both programs at the same time? Yes. There's no rule against being on a Housing Choice Voucher waiting list and a Project-Based Section 8 waiting list at the same time. In fact, doing both is one of the best ways to shorten your overall wait.
Does my credit score matter? Section 8 programs are based on income eligibility, not credit scores. However, individual landlords may still run a credit or background check as part of their own screening process before approving your lease.
What if I'm already renting somewhere? If you have a Housing Choice Voucher, you may be able to use it for your current home if your landlord agrees to participate and the unit passes inspection. Project-Based Section 8 doesn't work this way, since the subsidy is tied only to specific pre-approved units.
Will I lose my spot if I turn down a unit? Policies vary by housing authority and property, so check the specific rules where you've applied. Some allow a limited number of declines before removing you from the list, so read any notice you receive carefully.
Get instant answers to your housing questions.Chat Now
Which One Is Right for You?
Neither program is automatically "better" — it depends on what you need.
A Housing Choice Voucher may be a better fit if you want freedom to choose your neighborhood, you might need to relocate for work or family, or you already have a specific rental in mind.
Project-Based Section 8 may be a better fit if you want a shorter path to housing (project-based waiting lists are sometimes shorter than PHA-wide voucher lists), or if you're interested in housing built specifically for seniors or people with disabilities, since many project-based buildings are designed for those groups.
Whichever option looks like a better match, applying to both at the same time is completely allowed and often the smartest move. It increases your chances of getting help sooner.
Get instant answers to your housing questions.Chat Now
What's Changed Recently
Funding for both programs comes from Congress each year, and that funding can shift. As of 2026, both the Housing Choice Voucher program and Project-Based Section 8 remain active, and current participants continue receiving assistance. Congress has continued to fund both programs, even as broader debates about future housing policy continue in Washington. Because rules and funding levels can change, it's always worth double-checking current details directly with your local PHA or on HUD.gov before you apply.
Final Thoughts
Both Project-Based Section 8 and the Housing Choice Voucher exist for the same basic reason: to help make rent affordable for families, seniors, and people with disabilities who need support. The main thing to remember is where the subsidy "lives" — with you, or with the apartment.
If you're ready to start looking for openings near you, our partner site, Section8Search.org, can help you find current Section 8 and affordable housing listings in your area.
